Most back pain is not a surgical problem, and the best treatment is usually time, movement, and a good non-surgical plan.
As a spine surgeon, a big part of my job is helping people figure out whether surgery could help them at all. Often the honest answer is no, and that’s good news.
What surgery can and can’t fix
Spine surgery works best for specific, mechanical problems that show up on imaging and match your symptoms. Examples include:
A disc or bone spur pressing on a nerve, causing leg or arm pain, numbness, or weakness
Spinal stenosis that limits how far you can walk or stand
A slipping or unstable vertebra, or a spinal curve that is getting worse
Back pain on its own, without nerve symptoms, is different. It often comes from muscles, ligaments, joints, and discs that are irritated or aging. That kind of pain is hard to trace to one spot, and surgery is much less reliable at relieving it.
Your MRI isn’t the whole story
Disc bulges, “degeneration,” and arthritis show up on many MRIs, including in people who have no pain at all. These findings are often a normal part of aging. A finding only matters if it fits your symptoms and your exam. That’s why I look at the whole picture, not just the MRI report.
What usually helps instead
Staying active, with short rests rather than bed rest
Physical therapy focused on strength and movement
Short-term medications, as your doctor advises
Attention to sleep, stress, and overall fitness
Most flare-ups improve over several weeks. If yours isn’t getting better, the next step is a careful evaluation, not necessarily an operation. You can read more about non-surgical spine care.
The brain’s role: neuroplastic pain
Pain is produced by the brain, and it’s always real. But sometimes, especially when pain has lasted a long time, the nervous system keeps sending pain signals even after the original injury has healed. This is called neuroplastic pain: the brain has learned to keep the pain going. It often explains why back pain can be severe when the MRI looks fairly normal, or why it moves around, comes and goes with stress, or flares without a clear trigger.
The good news is that what the brain has learned, it can unlearn. Cognitive approaches retrain how the brain interprets signals from the body:
Pain Reprocessing Therapy (PRT) teaches people to see their pain as safe and to respond to it without fear. In a 2021 randomized trial published in JAMA Psychiatry, two-thirds of people with chronic back pain who received PRT were pain-free or nearly pain-free after treatment, and most kept those gains a year later. You can learn more and find trained practitioners at painreprocessingtherapy.com.
Books that many of my patients have found helpful include The Way Out by Alan Gordon, who developed PRT, and Healing Back Pain: The Mind-Body Connection by Dr. John Sarno, an early pioneer of the mind-body approach.
Cognitive behavioral therapy and mindfulness, often alongside physical therapy, can also lower pain and improve function.
These approaches work best when serious structural problems have been ruled out, which is part of what a careful spine evaluation does. For more resources, see my page on mind-body approaches to chronic pain.
When back pain doesn’t go away: finding the source
For back pain that lasts months despite good non-surgical care, the next step is finding out exactly where it’s coming from. A few tools help with that:
SPECT/CT scan. This combines a bone scan with a CT scan to show which joints or bones in the spine are actively inflamed. It helps pinpoint the source of pain, such as a specific facet joint, so treatment can be aimed at the right spot.
Medial branch blocks. The small facet joints at the back of the spine are a common source of chronic back pain. In this test, a small amount of numbing medicine is placed on the tiny nerves (medial branches) that carry pain signals from those joints. If your pain drops significantly afterward, those joints are likely the cause.
Targeted treatments that aren’t major surgery
Once the pain source is clear, there are options between therapy and a formal operation:
Radiofrequency ablation (RFA). If medial branch blocks confirm the facet joints as the source, RFA uses heat to turn off those small nerves. Relief often lasts many months, and the procedure can be repeated if the nerves grow back.
Intracept (basivertebral nerve ablation). Some chronic low back pain comes from inside the vertebrae themselves, called vertebrogenic pain. It shows up on MRI as specific changes near the disc (Modic changes). Intracept is an outpatient procedure that reaches the nerve inside the vertebra through a small access point and turns it off with heat. It’s for people with long-standing low back pain who haven’t improved after at least six months of non-surgical care.
ReActiv8 (restorative neurostimulation). In some people, chronic back pain is linked to deep spine-stabilizing muscles, the multifidus, that have stopped working properly. ReActiv8 is a small implanted device that stimulates the nerves to those muscles in short daily sessions, retraining them to support the spine. It’s for people with chronic mechanical low back pain who haven’t improved with other treatment and aren’t candidates for surgery.
Surgery is the last resort
A formal operation is reserved for when these steps haven’t helped, or when there’s a clear structural problem that surgery is known to fix.
When to be seen sooner
Get prompt medical care if back pain comes with:
New trouble controlling your bladder or bowels, or numbness in the groin or inner thighs (go to the ER)
Leg weakness that is getting worse
Fever, unexplained weight loss, a history of cancer, or a significant fall or injury
Seeing a spine surgeon doesn’t have to mean surgery. Sometimes the most useful thing I can tell you is that your spine is safe to keep moving and that a clear non-surgical plan is the right path.
If you’d like to talk through your options, request an appointment at Virtua Reconstructive Orthopaedics in Sewell or Cherry Hill, or call (609) 267-9400.
This article is for general education and is not medical advice.